Apple lawyer, FBI director face off in Congress on iPhone encryption
Updated: 2016-03-02 09:51
(Agencies)
|
|||||||||
FBI Director James Comey arrives for a House Judiciary hearing on "The Encryption Tightrope: Balancing Americans' Security and Privacy" on Capitol Hill in Washington March 1, 2016. [Photo/Agencies] |
The remarks were a slight change to Comey's statement last week that ordering Apple to unlock the phone was "unlikely to be a trailblazer" for setting a precedent for other cases.
Tuesday's testimony from Comey and remarks before the same US House Judiciary Committee by Apple's general counsel, Bruce Sewell, brought to Congress a public fight between Apple and the government over the dueling interests of privacy and security that has so far only been heard in the courts.
On Feb 16, a federal court in California instructed Apple to write special software to unlock the iPhone 5c used by gunman Rizwan Farook, an order the company is contesting.
Sewell and Comey's remarks also clarified some areas where the two sides fundamentally disagree. Comey said the tool created for Farook's iPhone would not work on other models. But Sewell said the tool that Apple was being asked to create would work on any iPhone.
"This is not about the San Bernardino case. This is about the safety and security of every iPhone that is in use today," Sewell said.
Committee members seized on Comey's statement that the case could set a legal precedent allowing the agency access to any encrypted device.
"Given... that Congress has explicitly denied you that authority so far, can you appreciate our frustration that this case appears to be little more than an end run around this committee?" asked the panel's ranking minority member, Michigan Representative John Conyers.
Related Stories
Apple fights back in court, refusing to hack into iPhone for FBI 2016-02-26 09:21
San Bernardino victims to oppose Apple on iPhone encryption 2016-02-22 10:22
Apple ordered to help FBI access terror killer's phone 2016-02-17 14:14
Today's Top News
British PM threatened with 'no confidence vote'
70,000 may become trapped in Greece
'Grow people' for long-term China-UK relations
Points of view
Small island makes a big difference
Rubio, Cruz gang up on Trump in debate ploy
'Invented-in-China’ products to the fore at MWC
Beijing edges NYC as home to most billionaires
Hot Topics
Lunar probe , China growth forecasts, Emission rules get tougher, China seen through 'colored lens', International board,
Editor's Picks
The price of a pretty face |
The Golden Triangle's time to shine |
Art that speaks a new language |
'China collapse' argument mistaken |
10 reasons to be optimistic |
Points of view |