Op-Ed Contributors

Expanding China-India cooperation

Updated: 2011-09-28 08:05

By Naren Chitty (China Daily)

Twitter Facebook Myspace Yahoo! Linkedin Mixx

India and China are neighboring ancient civilizations, which have exchanged people, goods and ideas over time. If mutual attraction for each other's deep philosophical values and culture, evident in their engagement with Buddhism, draws them together, geopolitics draws them apart. But the concept of harmony, the heart of Buddhism and Confucianism both, is the quintessence of both civilizations.

Today, India emphasizes the harmony of its union of states, marked by linguistic groups of incredible diversity. These groups are held together by the bonds of political pluralism, and its tourism slogan, "Incredible India", captures its demographic and democratic diversity.

China's emphasis is on a more cohesive genre of political order that values an unruffled harmony, which delivers prosperity efficiently. The projection of China to the world through the Beijing 2008 Olympic Games effectively delivered this message.

The two countries have quarrelled over their borders and even fought a war. In the 21st century, the heady mixture of huge populations and rapid industrialization has lifted China and India to new heights. But emerging powers have a propensity to compete strategically, so they need to be careful about nursing their quarrels.

It is a truism that competition engenders enemy images in the minds of competitors. Such reciprocal enemy imagery can be a tinderbox for rival power aspirants. While economic competition is to be encouraged, enemy imagery must be discouraged.

Certainly neighbors and partners of the two countries, like Australia, would like to see a healthy quantum of cooperation that outweighs the kind of competition that could lead to conflict.

Cooperation has an opposite effect on reciprocal images. It encourages positive images in the minds and media of the cooperating countries. The spilling over of positive images encourages cooperation in other areas, and the expanding spill dampens the tinderbox to create a mutually beneficial situation.

At the end of last year, Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao resolved in New Delhi to settle their border disputes. Their joint statement said: "There is enough space in the world for the development of both India and China, and indeed enough areas for India and China to cooperate." They agreed to cooperate in uprooting terrorists' finance networks in the region and sharing of the waters of the Brahmaputra River (Yarlung Zangbo River).

Australian security studies have shown that while China and India cooperate in security, diplomatic and economic spheres, their cooperation level in the first two is not high and in the second is unbalanced. While the frame of security analysis is important, it needs to be supplemented with the frame of communication and the advocacy of cooperation.

Australia, understandably, wants to see increased cooperation between China and India. In fact, Australia could play a role in facilitating cooperation between the two countries by allowing its high levels of development in science, technology, industry, education and media to play an important role.

The need of the epoch is a systematic expansion of cooperation between China and India. The statement of Singh and Wen provides a basis for this - as an expression of political will. A joint commission of the two countries can translate this political will into action, for example, by expanding soft power space of cooperation.

The two countries espouse different types of democratic systems but both are committed to rapid development as well as building safety nets for the poor. By getting together in a soft power space of cooperation they could cooperate in addressing some of their development challenges. A space of "credible harmony" - a term that collapses the individual branding of the two countries - would do wonders to churn out positive images of cooperation.

The two countries can consider four broadly shared soft power spaces: cooperation in space, health care, education and poverty alleviation. A pyramidal structure of research will ensure that solutions generated through space research filters down to terrestrial areas of health care, education and poverty alleviation.

China and India are no longer obsessed with GDP growth. Both have begun focusing on other values as well, such as quality, environmental protection, social security and creativity. Cooperation in designing safety nets and poverty alleviation will help improve the lives of those left behind by globalization in the two countries.

Social science research that helps us understand how various groups in China and India view the social and cultural aspects in the other country will be vital to the development of the shared soft power space. We know Indian films are popular among the Chinese. Which groups of Chinese like these films? What do they like about them? What frames of India does the Chinese audience have in mind? What do Indians think of Chinese films? Certainly, exchange of films, music and people should be one aspect of "credible harmony".

The attraction China and India have for each other and the core value of harmony can be the seed of the proposed shared soft power space. Political will has already been expressed at the highest levels. Now the machinery for implementation needs to be built and, hence, the notion of joint commission. "Credible harmony" will create tremendous opportunities for ordinary people both in China and India, as well as the region and the world beyond.

There is also need for parallel expansion of dialogue and cooperation between Chinese and Indian communities in Australia and throughout the world, for the maturity shown by Beijing and New Delhi can find excellent expression in cooperative inter-diasporic relations, too.

The author is foundation chair of the International Communication and inaugural director-designate of Soft Power Advocacy and Research Centre at Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia.

(China Daily 09/28/2011 page9)


Pearl paradise

Dreams of a 'crazy' man turned out to be a real pearler for city

Literary beacon
Venice of china
Up to the mark

European Edition


Power of profit

Western companies can learn from management practices of firms in emerging economies

Foreign-friendly skies

About a year ago, 48-year-old Roy Weinberg gave up his job with US Airways, moved to Shanghai and became a captain for China's Spring Airlines.

Plows, tough guys and real men

在这个时代,怎样才"够男人"? On the character "Man"

Test of character
Sowing the seeds of doubt
Lifting the veil