Fishermen, environmentalists see red over Alaska naval exercises

Updated: 2011-04-06 08:04

By Jacob Resneck (China Daily)

Twitter Facebook Myspace Yahoo! Linkedin Mixx

KODIAK, Alaska - Environmental groups and fishermen are sounding the alarm over planned US Navy live-fire exercises they claim threaten marine wildlife including whales in the Gulf of Alaska.

They are also angry at plans to sink a decommissioned warship in the northern Pacific, one of the most productive commercial fishing grounds in US waters, at the heart of Alaska's economy.

"I know the navy has to practice," said Alaska Marine Conservation Council Board Chairman Dave Kubiak, a commercial fisherman. "I just wonder why they have to do their practices in one of the richest fishing grounds in the world."

At the heart of the row is the navy's use of mid-frequency sonar which has documented links to the deaths of marine mammals in Mediterranean and Atlantic waters.

The navy plans to stage two 21-day joint anti-submarine exercises this summer in the Gulf of Alaska, as well as sink a decommissioned warship at least 90 km offshore.

The exercises would involve live-fire gunnery and using medium-frequency sonar to hunt submarines in the narrow underwater channels in a 145,482-sq-km area east of Kodiak Island.

Federal regulators downplay the threat even as environmentalists sound the alarm.

"There is certainly no denying that the activities that the navy does have impacts on marine mammals," said Jolie Harrison, a National Marine Fisheries Service biologist.

"But we've been working with them for several years to figure out how best to minimize those."

The five-year permit being finalized allows the disturbance of about 425,000 marine mammals per year. It also allows the incidental death of up to 15 beaked whales over five years.

The navy admits to five cases where military sonar was specifically linked to the stranding of marine mammals and the deaths of beaked whales.

The US Navy's use of medium-frequency sonar was involved in one of those cases, a 2000 incident that saw seven animals die in the Bahamas.

Environmentalists have challenged the navy's sonar plans, and a case reached the US Supreme Court in 2008 with a 5-4 court decision siding with the navy, although it did not completely exempt the military from complying with environmental laws.

In response, the navy agreed to undertake an environmental study which it completed this month that lays out its plans in detail. A formal decision is expected after the comment period closes on April 11.

"We use lookouts and acoustic devices that are on the ship to make sure we have cleared that area of marine mammals," said US Navy Pacific Command Environmental Planner Alex Stone.

The Natural Resources Defense Council, one of the navy's past legal adversaries, says it is skeptical.

"The navy can't impose any of these mitigation measures because it doesn't know the distribution or 'hot spots' (of marine habitat) in the area," said Taryn Kiekow, the council's staff attorney.

Agence France-Presse


Green mission

Tony blair believes China will take a leading role to fight climate change and cut emissions.

The spring of new professions
Real modern times
F1 sponsors expect returns from Shanghai stop

European Edition


Share your China stories!

Foreign readers are invited to share your China stories.

Have you any wool?

The new stars of Chinese animation are edging out old childhood icons like Mickey Mouse and Hello Kitty.

Fill dad's shoes

Daughter and son are beginning to take over the family business of making shoes.

Beloved polar bear died
Panic buying of salt
'Super moon'