Op-Ed Contributors
US public is paying the price
Updated: 2011-08-24 08:28
By Liu Weidong (China Daily)
The debt crisis has exposed the defects rather than the advantages of America's tit for tat democratic system
The US debt crisis has drawn much criticism both at home and aboard. It is inconceivable to many people that as the only superpower in the world the US was locked in a struggle that threatened to bring the wheels of state to a halt had the politicians not arrived at a last-minute compromise to raise the nation's debt limit in order to avoid a debt default.
As a country that always boasts it has the most "perfect" democratic system in the world, the US is not doing well in its domestic affairs and the debt crisis has exposed the defects rather than the advantages of its system. Even many US citizens have appealed for introspection and reform of the country's political system.
The core of the US democratic system is the representative system of government and the separation of the executive, legislative and judicial powers. People have the right to elect representatives they support, and these representatives are mandated to protect voters' interests. The separation of the three powers is supposed to guarantee a system of check and balances.
Such a political system has been regarded by some as the most advanced form of governance in human history, but it has been inefficient and powerless in the face of the problems the US is facing now.
First, from the perspective of the representative system, the public has the right to elect their agents, but it's hard to deprive the agents of their rights immediately if they are incompetent or crooked. Theoretically, when representative government does not work effectively and there is a deadlock between the rival parties, the government can resort to a referendum to get legitimacy and break the deadlock.
But the power of decision resides in the politicians, who will not easily hand it over. Moreover, it's hard to practice because of practical difficulties. The US has never resorted to a referendum to settle disputes when the government has reached a deadlock over public policy.
Moreover, the public has the right to depose elected officials in office, but it is restricted to lower-ranking officials, not the federal senators. So although many citizens have demonstrated in front of Capitol Hill and protested through the media, they don't have any decision-making power.
E-paper
Blue economy gets a lift
Coastal areas of Shandong, Zhejiang and Guangdong to spearhead sector development.
The light touch
Long way to go
Outdoor success
Specials
Star journalist remembered
Friends, colleagues attended a memorial service to pay tribute to veteran reporter Li Xing in US.
Hot pots
Tea-making treasures catch the fancy of connoisseurs as record prices brew up interest
Hear we go
Polish Audiologist helps thousands of Chinese hear for the first time.