Size matters, but so does how it is calculated
Updated: 2014-10-14 11:21
By Zheng Yanpeng(China Daily)
|
|||||||||||
China has overtaken the United States as the world's largest economy this year, according to the International Monetary Fund's latest estimate. But unlike four years ago, when China eclipsed Japan as the world's second-largest economy, this time the news sparked muted reaction and doubts.
Measuring GDP using purchasing power parity, the IMF estimated China's GDP at $17.6 trillion, against $17.4 trillion for the US, ending the latter's position at the top that it held since 1872.
One reason for the doubts is that not everyone agrees about the validity of measuring GDP in terms of PPP.
Domestic media were quick to point to flaws in the PPP calculation, saying this method tends to overestimate developing countries' economic might.
Economists noted that measured by nominal GDP, a more common method of making cross-country comparisons, China's GDP in 2013 was 55 percent of that of the US.
Comparing figures for per capita GDP were even more revealing: China's per capita GDP, standing at $6,807 in 2013, was just 12.8 percent of that of the US.
Even in PPP terms, China's GDP per capita was only 22.4 percent of that of the US.
Some commentators even speculated that the IMF's announcement was meant to "disarm" China by excessively complimenting it. There is no evidence to back up that interpretation. Despite its irrelevance in ordinary people's lives, PPP can help economists understand different nations' economic strengths and overcome exchange-rate distortions.
But even GDP measured in PPP terms is one way to understand the sheer size of the economy, Chinese people know well that the country has many goals beyond the pursuit of GDP.
It is logical that China, with its vast area and the world's largest population, would eventually have the largest economy. But size does not make one great.
"China will definitely be the largest economic power, sooner or later. But that is not what ordinary Chinese care about. At the end of the day, ordinary Chinese care about their incomes," Alfred Schipke, senior resident representative of the IMF in China, said in May after similar economic claims emerged.
Speaking of incomes, China has more reasons to worry than to celebrate. Leaving aside the nation's vast income disparities, household incomes have remained disproportionately small while government income has grown disproportionately large in the composition of GDP.
|
|
IMF official: Growth slowdown welcome | China needs to boost productivity to sustain growth: IMF |
Related Stories
A tick for graft fight, but much more is needed 2014-10-13 14:26
IMF risks irrelevance without change, experts say 2014-10-13 08:19
Chinese economy to expand at steady pace 2014-10-13 09:11
Chinese economy to pick up in Q4 2014-10-13 10:17
China needs no "big stimulus" despite slowdown 2014-10-13 09:39
China is a driving force for world economic recovery 2014-10-13 09:25
Today's Top News
Premier Li in Russia to boost trade ties
China's exports jump 15.3%
IMF risks irrelevance without change, experts say
China bites into US carp problem
China's economic slowdown 'welcomed'
HK chief urges lawful reform
Second Ebola case in US caused by 'breach in protocol'
China, Germany sign $18.1 billion deals
Hot Topics
Lunar probe , China growth forecasts, Emission rules get tougher, China seen through 'colored lens', International board,
Editor's Picks
Sea change |
'Old newcomers' |
General aviation hub reaches for the sky |
Endangered species threatens livelihoods |
Chinese mavericks set to amaze racing world |
Helping them breathing |